Editor's Pick

TJ Maxx, Marshalls CEO makes holiday price promise rivals will hate

TJ Maxx and Marshalls may have a customer problem that goes beyond whether shoppers still like their stores. As living costs rise and household budgets remain under pressure, consumers are becoming more careful about where they spend their money. And that is putting the retailers’ value proposition to the test.

In an October report, TheStreetCo-Editor-in-Chief Todd Campbell examined the issue, citing Morgan Stanley research that pointed to weaker customer transactions and growing concerns about whether TJ Maxx and Marshalls still offer the value shoppers expect.

The latest results suggest that the challenge has not entirely disappeared for these chains’ parent company, TJX. Marmaxx, the TJX division that includes TJ Maxx and Marshalls, reported essentially flat customer transactions in its latest quarter. Comparable sales growth was instead supported by customers spending more per transaction.

Morgan Stanley had identified the holiday season as an important period to watch, as stronger consumer spending could help improve the retailers’ performance.

Now, TJX CEO Ernie Herrman has a direct message for shoppers who are watching their budgets. During the company’s latest earnings call, he made a promise about prices that could put competing retailers on notice.

TJ Maxx, Marshalls CEO promises to undercut rivals’ prices

During the Nov. 18 earnings call, TJX CEO Ernie Herrman made a particularly direct statement about the company’s pricing strategy, saying its merchants would adjust retail prices when competitors cut prices to ensure TJX maintains its price advantage across its retail businesses.

“Our merchants are extremely diligent on comp shopping all competitors. Again, it’s not just off-price. They comp all competitors on the out-the-door retail,” Herrman told analysts. 

That means TJX does not just compare its prices with the regular prices listed by department stores or other retailers. It also monitors promotional prices, including discounts offered by online retailers and wholesale clubs.

“We will make sure and ensure that we are the lowest price there,” Herrman said.

The CEO added that TJX has already lowered its own retail prices in certain categories after competitors reduced theirs. The goal, he explained, is to maintain the same price gap that shoppers have come to expect from the retailer.

This is particularly important because TJX’s pricing model is built around offering branded and designer merchandise at lower prices than traditional retailers. In its latest annual report, the company said its prices are generally 20% to 60% below the regular prices charged by full-price retailers for comparable merchandise.

TJX’s CEO makes a holiday price promise rivals will hate.

Jeff Greenberg / Getty Images

Shoppers want value, but aren’t skipping the holidays

The latest consumer survey reveals why TJX’s new pricing promise might resonate with shoppers this holiday season. 

According to the National Retail Federation’s October 2026 holiday survey, more than three-quarters of shoppers plan to take steps to cover the cost of holiday purchases.

The most common strategy is cutting back on non-holiday spending, which 32% of consumers said they planned to do. Another 22% said they would buy fewer items for themselves.

The findings suggest that shoppers are not necessarily giving up on holiday celebrations. They are simply making trade-offs to afford them.

A separate study from Circana found that consumers expect to spend an average of $779 during the 2026 holiday season, down from $796 last year. The survey of 3,534 U.S. consumers also found that 74% of shoppers expect to adopt money-saving behaviors, including looking for promotions, seeking deals, and purchasing store brands.

“Consumers are not abandoning holiday spending, they’re becoming increasingly purposeful about where and how they spend,” stated Kiara Barrett, head of global thought leadership at Circana.

For TJX, these spending habits make its pricing strategy particularly important heading into the holidays. 

Morgan Stanley had already identified the season as a potential opportunity for TJ Maxx and Marshalls to regain momentum. Now, Herrman’s promise to keep prices below those of competing retailers on comparable merchandise gives shoppers another reason to consider the stores when looking for holiday bargains.

TJX numbers reveal why the price promise matters now

TJX’s latest results were generally strong. The company reported third-quarter net sales of $16 billion, up 6% from a year earlier. Comparable sales increased 4% across the business, according to the company’s official press release. 

But its largest U.S. division, Marmaxx, which includes TJ Maxx, Marshalls, and Sierra, delivered more modest growth.

Marmaxx’s comp sales growth was driven by a higher average basket, and customer transactions were essentially flat. Marmaxx’s adjusted segment profit margin was 13.8%, down 110 basis points versus last year, primarily driven by higher freight and fuel costs, TJX Companies CFO John Klinger noted.  

“At our Sierra stores, we are happy with the sales we are seeing as we expand that chain across the U.S.,” Klinger said. 

Marmaxx generated more sales from shoppers’ purchases, but it did not report an increase in customer transactions during the quarter.

Meanwhile, HomeGoods comparable sales increased 5%, TJX Canada rose 6%, and TJX International increased 8%. Growth at HomeGoods and TJX Canada was driven by both higher customer transactions and larger average baskets, while TJX International’s increase came primarily from in customer transactions.

CEO Herrman said Marmaxx’s performance improved during the second half of the quarter. He also expects further improvement during the holiday period.

Still, the company has reasons to make sure customers continue to see its stores as worthwhile shopping destinations.

BofA sees path to improvement for TJX

Bank of America analyst Lorraine Hutchinson sees reasons for optimism heading into the holiday season.

In a recent analysis shared with TheStreet, she pointed to progress in addressing buying issues, a strong holiday assortment backed by marketing campaigns, and healthy inventory levels that would allow TJX to keep bringing in new merchandise as factors supporting a potential improvement in Marmaxx’s fourth-quarter sales.

Related: Toys “R” Us is making a major comeback

“After several quarters of raising prices, TJX lowered prices on certain items to compete on value in the market. This is normal course of business, and mgmt maintains it has not seen customer pushback on specific products where it had raised prices,” Hutchinson wrote. 

For shoppers, this could mean more competitive prices and a steady flow of new merchandise as TJX brands try to attract budget-conscious customers during the holiday season.

TJ Maxx, Marshalls have another strategy to keep shoppers coming back

Herrman also highlighted another part of TJX’s holiday strategy: keeping fresh merchandise flowing into stores throughout the season.

The company expects new merchandise and gift items to arrive multiple times a week, with significant quantities still reaching stores as late as 10 days before Christmas.

“We create an opportunity for a consumer that doesn’t want to go online and wants something fresh when a lot of stores are picked over, they can come into TJ Maxx or Marshalls and find something there that is just landing 10 days before Christmas, which I think is really groundbreaking in terms of the approach from what other retailers do,” Herrman said. 

That means shoppers visiting TJ Maxx and Marshalls closer to the holiday could still find newly delivered merchandise, rather than just leftovers from earlier shopping weeks. For customers, it’s an opportunity for last-minute deals, even in the final days of the shopping season.

Related: What happens after Walmart leaves town is worse than expected